When you look at a rental property, four numbers come up again and again: net operating income, cap rate, cash-on-cash return, and the debt service coverage ratio. Each one answers a different question. None of them, alone, tells you whether a property is a good fit.
This is the same framework our own rental cash-flow calculator uses. It's general education, not investment advice.
1. Net operating income (NOI)
Question it answers: How much does the property earn before the mortgage?
Formula: NOI = rental income + other income − operating expenses
Operating expenses include property taxes, insurance, utilities the owner pays, and money set aside for vacancy, repairs, capital items (like a roof or furnace), and management. Mortgage payments are not operating expenses, which is what lets you compare properties regardless of how they're financed.
Where it misleads: NOI is only as good as the expense estimates. A seller's numbers may leave out vacancy, management, or capital items. Build your own.
2. Cap rate
Question it answers: What does the property earn relative to its price, before financing?
Formula: Cap rate = annual NOI ÷ purchase price
If a property has $18,000 of annual NOI and costs $300,000, its cap rate is 6.0%. (That's an illustration, not a typical or recommended figure.)
Where it misleads: Cap rate ignores financing, so it says nothing about your monthly cash flow. It is also very sensitive to NOI: a small change in expenses can move it a lot. Try it with our cap rate calculator.
3. Cash-on-cash return
Question it answers: What does the property return on the cash you actually put in?
Formula: Cash-on-cash = annual cash flow after the mortgage ÷ total cash invested
Total cash invested includes the down payment, closing costs, and any upfront repairs.
Where it misleads: It's a one-year snapshot. It doesn't capture loan paydown, changes in value, taxes, or a large repair next year.
4. Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR)
Question it answers: Does the property's income cover the loan payment, and by how much?
Formula: DSCR = annual NOI ÷ annual mortgage payments
A DSCR of 1.0 means NOI exactly covers the mortgage, with nothing to spare. Our calculator flags anything under 1.25 so you can see when the cushion is thin. Lenders set their own requirements, so ask yours.
Put them together
Each number checks a different risk:
- NOI checks whether the building earns money on its own.
- Cap rate checks the price relative to that income.
- Cash-on-cash checks the return on your actual cash.
- DSCR checks whether the income can carry the debt.
A property can look good on one and poor on another. That's why it helps to see all four side by side and to change the assumptions to see how sensitive the results are.
Before you rely on any of it
Use real quotes for taxes, insurance, and financing. Use actual comparable rents, not projections. For context on local prices and rents, see our Northeast Wisconsin market snapshot. And talk with a lender, a CPA, and an attorney before you commit.
This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by a human. It is general information, not financial, legal, tax, or real estate advice. MidWe is not a real estate broker or agent.
